German Bundestag Approves Second Greek Bailout
As expected:- GERMAN PARLIAMENT APPROVES SECOND GREEK BAILOUT - BBG
- GERMAN PARLIAMENT VOTE 496 IN FAVOR, 90 AGAINST, 5 ABSTAIN - BBG
Mountain Of Worry Shifts From Olympus To Zagros
Like sands through the hour-glass, these are the fears of our lives. Just as we noted last week, the focus of risk is shifting from Greece (where while 'tail-risk' has perhaps receded for now, it is all-but certain that the insolvency predicament will resurface as a source of political, policy, and market tension in the not-too-distant future) to other foot-holds on the growing wall-of-worry. As UBS' Larry Hatheway notes this week, several candidates may replace Greece in the risk headlines, among them rising bond yields, French elections, or a Chinese hard landing. But his sense, and ours, is that oil prices will become the next risk item for market participants. Partly this is because oil prices are already approaching levels where worries have occurred in the past (and the velocity of the move is also empirically troublesome) and partly as the remedy for all global-ills (that of central bank printing) is implicitly impacting this 'risk' in a vicious circle. With global growth expectations already low, the 0.2ppt drop in Global GDP for each $10/bbl rise in oil will do nothing for Europe and US hope - and leaves Central Banks in that dangerous position of reinflating their low core inflation data while all around them is inflating rapidly. With modest schadenfreude, we remind readers of our comments from last week: "Alas, as noted previously, the central bank tsunami is only just starting. Watch for inflation, and concerns thereof, to slowly seep into everything". Given oil's potential 'real' impact, as SocGen notes: "Perhaps Greece wasn't so bad after all."Performance of Stocks, Bonds, and Gold In an Inflationary Environment
Everything Not Nailed Down Being Bought
When in doubt - buy. When in doubt what - everything. As the chart below shows starting with the open of the US market, literally everything has been bought: stocks, bonds, crude, gold, and 'logically', the VIX. It took the market virtually no time to remember that when trillions in liquidity are being injected into the market courtesy of central planners, a downtick is verboten. Next up: waiting for WTI $110. Should take a few minutes at most.
Guest Post: The Perfection Of Crony Capitalism: Use Regulation To Destroy Competitors
In the U.S. we now have the perfection of cloaked crony capitalism:
corporate cartels use their vast concentrations of capital and revenue
to buy the political leverage needed to write regulations specifically
designed to eliminate competition. Recall that the most profitable business model is a monopoly or cartel protected from competition by the coercive Central State.
Imposing complex regulations on small business competitors effectively
cripples an entire class competitors, but does so in "stealth
mode"--after all, more regulations are a "good thing" (especially to
credulous Liberals) which "protect the public" (and every politico loves
claiming his/her new raft of regulations will "protect the public.") This masks the key dynamic of crony capitalism: gaming the government is the most profitable business model.
Where else can you "invest" a few hundred thousand dollars (to buy
political "access" and lobbying) and "earn" a return in the millions of
dollars, and eliminate potential competitors, too? No other
"investment" even comes close.
Here Is Why Someone Will Be Disappointed By The LTRO
Gaming out the impact of this week's LTRO2 demand on global risk assets is complicated by the ability of banks to mobilize collateral (how much can they pledge to the ECB and how much of that will be 'optimal' given the implicit subordination of senior unsecured debt holders), the use of those funds (carry trade economics are considerably lower and refinancing needs remain high), and the market's expectations (just how much more back-door QE is priced into European - and for that matter - US asset prices). Goldman Sachs surveyed its clients and found a gaping divide between banks and investors with the latter expecting considerably more than the banks - it seems someone will be disappointed - investors hope for more and banks expect to do less.Live Video Webcast From The Bundestag
As various German party heads and other flacks complete their
prepared remarks over the second Greek bailout, we get closer to the
actual bailout vote. Unlike on previous occasions, the atmosphere
toward Greece this time around is far more hostile. Granted, a down
vote will likely have the same impact on markets as Congress voting
down the first TARP so is highly unlikely, but for those eager for
political drama this is your webcast.
LTRO 2 101: Top-Down
With the second version of the ECB's enhanced LTRO (back-door QE) starting tomorrow, there has been a great deal of speculation on what the take-up will be, what banks will do with the funds they receive, and more importantly how will this effect global asset markets. SocGen provides a comprehensive top-down analysis of the drivers of LTRO demand, the likely uses of those funds, and estimates how much of this will be used to finance the carry trade (placebo or no placebo). Italian (25%) and Spanish (20%) banks are unsurprisingly at the forefront in their take-up of ECB liquidity (likely undertaking the M.A.D. reach-around carry trade ) and have been since long before the first LTRO. On the other side, German banks have dramatically reduced their collective share of ECB liquidity from 30% to only 6%. SocGen skews their detailed forecast to EUR300-400bn, disappointing relative to the near EUR500bn consensus - and so likely modestly bad news for risk assets. Furthermore, they expect around EUR116bn of this to be used for carry trade 'revenue' production which will however lead to only a 0.6% improvement in sectoral equity levels (though some banks will benefit more than others), as they discuss the misunderstanding of LTRO-to-ECB-deposit facility rotation. We, however, remind readers that collateralized (and self-subordinating) debt is not a substitute for capital and if the ECB adamantly defines this as the last enhanced LTRO (until the next one of course) then European banks face an uphill battle without that crutch - whether or not they even have collateral to post. Its further important to note that LTRO 2 cannot be wholly disentangled from the March 1-2 EU Summit event risk and we fear expectations, priced into markets, are a little excessive. We suspect this will not be a Goldilocks 'just right' moment.Merkel: "No Guarantee Second Greek Bailout Will Work"
It was only logical that following this weekend's quote unquote surprise announcement by Juncker that a third Greek bailout is likely in the cards,
that Angela Merkel would follow up during her much anticipated
Bundestag speech today and tell fellow politicians that there is no
guarantee that a Greek bailout will work. That was to be expected. That
this announcement is somehow responsible for the market selling off,
and the EURUSD being at the lows of the day, once again proves that the
market is no longer a discounting mechanism, and merely reacts to
headlines that could be anticipated by anyone who steps back from the
blaring noise and flashing headlines for even just one minute.
Art Cashin On The World Running Out Of Ideas To Bail Out Itself
A big reason for the dour mood overcast on the market this morning is
the failure of G-20 to resolve latent funding issues, with the IMF
demanding more money from Germany for a global firewall, and Germany
demanding more money from everyone else. A way to summarize events is
that in lieu of any credible collateral left (the bulk of it has and
will be pledged with the ECB in its discount window, aka LTRO
operations, to keep Italian bonds bid and thus perpetuate the fallacy
that things are under control), the world is now running out of ideas
how to even kick the can down the road. Which is not a good sign as much
kicking remains with tens of trillions in debt rollover coming up in
the next few years. Below is Art Cashin's summary of this weekend's
disappointing G-20 weekend retreat in Cabo san Lucas, which enjoyed the
scenery but did nothing to easy the confusion over who pays for what in
the next few weeks.
Guest Post: The Trajectory Of Tragedy
With an economy of just $3.2Tn versus the United States $14.3Tn
Germany is trying to prop up a Eurozone that is more than one trillion
dollars bigger than America. They just do not have the resources for the
task they are undertaking and I predict serious consequences,
eventually, from their efforts. Germany is “best of class” and will be
the last to go but they cannot evade the European recession in the end
and I think it is only a matter of time and unfortunate decisions before
the austerity demands made on so many will wind their way back home to
those who made the demands. They used a timeline that was much too short
for the job at hand and payment will eventually be forced upon them.
They obviously get the joke where Eurobonds and other ploys of this
nature average the economies of Europe and the standards of living over
some period of time so that Germany, in the end, will suffer most as
they have the furthest to fall. They have approached the G-20, China,
the emerging market countries and all polite responses to the side; the
results have been about zip. The Germans are running out of both time
and money and Franz is squirming in the beer hall.
Warren Buffett Favors Wells As The "Single Best Bank To Own": A Comparative Returns Analysis
Following on his latest bash session of gold from the weekend, when Warren Buffett dedicated a substantial portion of his annual letter to shareholders for the now routine and perfectly expected gold blasting, the Octogenarian of Omaha revealed to his faithful personal scribe Becky Quick that of all banks, he would recommend Wells Fargo as the single best bank to own. Naturally, as was previously lampooned by William Banzai, Americans, even those paying a 15% tax rate, would "do absolutely nothing for Warren trading book" if they were to buy gold instead of pooling their cash into the ponzi. As for buying WFC vs. gold, the chart below will show why the world is increasingly taking any proclamations from the man whose net worth was bailed out by the government, with humor more than serious consideration.Presenting the past decade's return of Wells Fargo and of gold. No commentary necessary.
The (European) Placebo Effect
The “Placebo Effect” is fascinating. In a typical drug testing
trial, one group of patients will receive the actual drug being tested,
and a “control” group will be given an “inert” medicine (or “sugar
pill”) that shouldn’t do anything for the patient, but the patient
doesn’t know that. So much of what I find wrong about “economics” is
that it masquerades as far more of a science than it actually is. It
doesn’t have theories that can be “tested” in a real world, where 2
similar situations are treated differently to see which “treatment”
works better. Each economy and each situation is so different that it
is IMPOSSIBLE to determine why policies failed or what should have been
done differently. It is possible to come up with reasonable ideas and
theories of what could have been done or should have been done, but they
are only theories. The systems are so complex that finding situations
with similar starting conditions with similarly motivated entities
involved is simply impossible to find. The fact that so much of our
policy seems to be based on research into what should have been done in
the Great Depression and what has been seen in Japan is frankly scary.
There is no way to “know” how the Great Depression would have turned
out with a different set of policies. We can make conjectures, but that
is all they are – conjectures. The LTRO was designed to support the
market, the market is up, so the LTRO must be working. That at least is
the logic many investors are applying. They see the improvement in
sovereign debt yields, the avalanche of “positive” (if unfounded)
headlines, and the relentless march higher of the stock market. So the
plan is working? Not so fast.
No comments:
Post a Comment